This community is for risk managers who wish to discuss India specific risks. The members include risk managers in India and those who wish to do business in India
82 Members

You need to be a member of Global Risk Community to add comments!

Join Global Risk Community

Comments are closed.

Comments

  • Interesting article in Strategy + Business- A Gandhian Approach to R&D

    http://www.strategy-business.com/article/10310?pg=1
  • Check out the blog post tommorrow, there is a pleasant surprise : http://soniajaspal.wordpress.com
  • My use of the term "sensitive" was to emphasize the nature of challenges in this sphere of financial activity and risk taking. My experience in micro financing dates back to late seventies.

    This segment is a good market - in the sense that it is a felt need. At the same time, given the Indian culture, particularly , political, it is a challenging task. Your concerns are shared by the States like Andhra Pradesh, West Bengal and Kerala where the problem of higher interest rates and employment of recovery agents for recovery have drawn official responses resulting in the review by RBI.

    I believe the solution lies in strengthening rural markets so that the rural poor have chances for poverty alleviation within their command area than relying on increasing the cost of marketing by looking to urban markets. In India, we need to move from Metropolitization to Ruralization - providing self sufficient communities, who can expect to achieve a reasonable standard of living. Development of SEZ will provide a good market for the farmers - but this will, initially, at least need government intervention.

    There are connected issues here as well. Such as the inflationary trends in basic food prices.

    Well, are there solutions that do not create fresh problems?

    I am veering round to the conclusion that life is one of managing solutions, not problems!
  • Seshadri, thanks for sharing your viewpoints. I agree with you comletely. I specially like your point that the poor should not bear the cost of their own upliftment by paying higher interests.

    My concern is that though it looks like the government has finally acknowledged the problems, they will again do the paper policies and there will be no change at the farmer level. And we will have to see many more suicides by the farmers.

    What do you say?

    Sonia
  • Sonia,
    Government has been doing a lot - both on disbursement and waivers - which has been a contentious issue with commercial bankers. While the disbursements to weaker sections have been encouraged by a carrot and stick approach using targets and subsidised interest rates, the waivers have been a dampener in terms of repayment psychology of the borrowers.

    The Micro Finance domain is a sensitive and challenging area. As Deepak points out, if social uplift is the primary objective of Micro Finance, the profit motive becomes an anathema.

    For a healthy growth of MFI sector, I believe there is a need for a balance between the social objective and profitabillity to ensure sustainability of MFI operations. That in the first place was the basis for certain target oriented lending approach - a policy stance adopted by the RBI. It is also not fair to ask the poor to bear the cost of their uplift by charging a hefty margin, though they should be morally inclined to pay back the society during their prosperity. Setting up of the committee by theRBI to review the position, in my interpretation, reflects this stance.

    NABARD is the natural choice for regulatory role as it is the key player in formulating the schemes for social uplift in the context of rural poverty. In fact, the legislation on MFIs should necessarily include tenets of financial inclusion that also touchbases with urban poor.

    At the end of the day, if MFIs are able to reach out to the rural poor, energise them to achieve liberation from the debt trap and still make a decent margin through improved reach, business processes and a commitment to sustained service, such MFIs should be allowed to flourish within the accepted banking practices for credit delivery and recovery.

    MFI is essentially engaged in a banking activity and thus required to be brought under the purview of RBI regulatory framework keeping in view the specific objectives for which the MFIs are estabilshed in the first place.

    My two cents...
    Seshadri
  • Deepak, great thought process. Hope finally the government does something for the poor farmers.

    Sonia
  • Till MFIs will run for profit it's not going to follow its core object of social upliftment. Basic idea behind establishment of these MFIs was to save poor from moneylenders. But currently they are no different from moneylenders in terms of interest charged by them and recent cases of forceful recovery strengthen this argument. With profit motive first there is pressure to distribute loans then to recover and these lead to malpractices. If this sector has to survive and wants to prosper then they have to do stick to their core objective i.e. helping the poors. In my view

    1. First profit making MFIs should not be allowed to operate as this will always lead to malpractice in the industry and if not possible then major percentage should go back to borrowers as relief or rebate.
    2. Interest rate should come down. Benefit of priority sector interest rate enjoyed by MFIs should be passed on to its borrowers.
    3. Part of profit should go back to these borrowers rather than entire thing going to investors.
    4. Licensing should be stricter and only a few MFIs should be allowed to operate in a region avoiding unnecessary competition between them.
    5. Financial discipline should be brought to the sector in terms of reporting correct numbers, strict audit controls preferably C&AG allotted audits and other control to ensure reported numbers are authentic.
    6. Finally a strict regulator like RBI.

    Hope these measures help industry to win its respect back and remove vultures out of this industry.
  • Microfinance Institutions dispute. AP government setting new norms. However in AP the government itself has a sector for distributing loans. So is it working for the benefit of the society or creating monopolistic situation.

    RBI has set a committee for establishing new norms.

    SIDBi takes responsibility for not monitoring MFI's properly.

    The latest headline - NABARD expected to control MFI's soon.

    What do you think should be done and will happen?
This reply was deleted.

Income Tax Return Filing in India

Income Tax Return (ITR) is a form that you fill out to disclose the details of your earnings from different sources and pay taxes to the Income Tax Department. ITRs include all information about an individual's earnings and tax-saving investments for a given financial year. Benefits of Filing Income Tax Returns Proper Documentation of Financials To Avoid Notice from the Income Tax Authority Carry Forward Losses Income Tax Refund For Speedy Visa Processing   Click here to know more - Income…

Read more…
0 Replies

How to get MSME Registration in India

MSME stands for micro, small, and medium enterprises, and MSME was set up to promote, facilitate, and develop the competitiveness of the micro, small, and medium enterprises. In a developing country like India, MSME industries are the backbone of the economy. Get MSME Registration Online in India with Enterslice. Visit our official website to know more about MSME Registration Process in India.

Read more…
0 Replies

Can white collar crime be written as fiction

Hi all, Am here after a long time. I need some feedback from risk managers. I am exploring the option of writing a book with stories in it, to simplify white collar crime and an investigators job. I have written a series of articles under the title Blog War ( Part I to VIII) on my blog http://soniajaspal.wordpress.com I wish to know whether this is kind of workable aspect of a book, will readers prefer this instead of the technical jargon. Also, as auditors/ investigators how would you respond…

Read more…
0 Replies

    About Us

    The GlobalRisk Community is a thriving community of risk managers and associated service providers. Our purpose is to foster business, networking and educational explorations among members. Our goal is to be the worlds premier Risk forum and contribute to better understanding of the complex world of risk.

    Business Partners

    For companies wanting to create a greater visibility for their products and services among their prospects in the Risk market: Send your business partnership request by filling in the form here!

lead