Beyond Nudging

8219692657?profile=originalSometimes you need to go beyond nudging decision makers. However, the personal risk you take when challenging a decision depends on culture.

Last week I was given cause to reflect on my time at HIH Insurance and the causes of its demise in 2001. While there were many, and people with different lenses could easily come to different conclusions, my view is that the culture did not allow sufficient leaders to speak their mind.

The CEO, Ray Williams, was a powerful personality. One of the most caring, thoughtful and engaging leaders I have experienced. He was able to inspire belief in the mission. Unfortunately, he was so good, it was not part of the culture of the organisation to criticise him.

Ray also put great trust in his senior leaders. Many had been with him for more than two decades. And without the checks and balances now expected in modern insurance companies, one senior leader after another were able to dig themselves into a financial hole that ultimately the organisation could not dig itself out.

Many risk professionals see their job as one of “oversight and challenge”. My message to them is, unless you have a very mature culture where the psychological safety exists for open and consequence-free questioning of decision makers, stating that your role is to oversee and challenge makes your job more difficult. I say to them:

“Senior leaders like being challenged ………. when proven right! And nobody on this planet likes to be ‘oversighted’!”

So instead of having the difficult conversation decision after decision, a smarter approach is to have one big conversation about the extent that psychological safety exists in the organisation so people can raise their voices, be heard and feel safe to do so.

Stay safe and adapt.



Bryan's new book teaches you practical methods to cut through with your advice and make the impact you want to make. Available on Amazon or order here now.



Available on Amazon or order here now.

Bryan Whitefield works with strategic leaders across all sectors to help organisations harness uncertainty – uncertainty is the strategic leader’s best friend. He is the author of DECIDE: How to Manage the Risk in Your Decision Making and Winning Conversations: How to turn red tape into blue ribbon. He is the designer of the Risk Culture: Build Your Tribe of Advocates Program for support functions and the Persuasive Adviser Program for internal advisers. Both can be booked individually or in-house. For more information about Bryan, please click here.

Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

Bryan is a management consultant operating since 2001, specialising in risk-based decision making and influencing decision makers, born from his more than twenty years of facilitating executive and board workshops.

Bryan’s experience as a risk practitioner includes the design and implementation of risk management programs for more than 150 organisations across the public, private and not-for-profit sectors.

Bryan is the author of Risky Business : How Successful Organisations Embrace Uncertainty; Persuasive Advising : How to Turn Red Tape into Blue Ribbon, and Team Think : Unlock the Power of the Collective Mind [to be published in 2022].

He is licenced by the RMIA as a Certified Chief Risk Officer (CCRO) and is the designer and facilitator of their flagship Enterprise Risk Course since 2019.

<a href=""></a>

You need to be a member of Global Risk Community to add comments!

Join Global Risk Community

    About Us

    The GlobalRisk Community is a thriving community of risk managers and associated service providers. Our purpose is to foster business, networking and educational explorations among members. Our goal is to be the worlds premier Risk forum and contribute to better understanding of the complex world of risk.

    Business Partners

    For companies wanting to create a greater visibility for their products and services among their prospects in the Risk market: Send your business partnership request by filling in the form here!