Every time a new tariff headline hits, the same tired playbook comes out. Panic meeting. Quick price review. Knee-jerk supplier calls. A memo to “monitor developments.” This is not Strategy. This is playing whack-a-mole while the floor is shifting under you.
Tariffs today aren’t isolated events—they are part of an ongoing realignment of global trade. Retaliatory measures, targeted sector restrictions, and politically motivated policy swings have hardwired volatility into the system. This isn’t about riding out the storm. It’s about operating in the storm indefinitely.
Enter the Tariffs and Global Trade: The Economic Impact on Business framework. It’s not another whiteboard session about “being agile.” It’s a three-phase process for moving from reflex to precision:
- Analyze Positioning
- Define Strategic Actions
- Stress Test Decisions
Source: https://flevy.com/browse/flevypro/tariffs-and-global-trade-the-economic-impact-on-business-9834
The heart of the framework is the Tariff Impact Matrix—a brutally simple tool with two dimensions:
- Relative Competitive Advantage: Your cost position and market access compared to peers, either improving or declining under tariffs.
- Customer Demand: Whether demand for your offering is growing or shrinking as trade flows shift.
This gives four strategic quadrants:
- Scale Up (costs improving, demand growing): Expand hard and fast.
- Defend Margins (costs improving, demand shrinking): Play defense with efficiency and share capture.
- Restructure (costs worsening, demand growing): Fix cost base before growth window closes.
- Streamline Focus (costs worsening, demand shrinking): Exit weak spots and concentrate on resilient areas.
If you don’t know your quadrant, you are operating blind. And when you are blind, speed just gets you to the wrong place faster.
Let’s discuss the first two phases of the model, for now.
Phase 1: Analyze Positioning
The analysis isn’t just about counting how much tariffs will cost you. It’s about finding out whether your pain is less—or more—than your competitors’. It’s about identifying if that market you have served for years is still worth the effort or if demand has simply evaporated.
The Tariff Impact Matrix is where reality replaces guesswork. Mapping yourself against both dimensions forces clarity: maybe your margin erosion is ugly, but if everyone else’s is worse, you have an opening. Or maybe you have been assuming demand is stable, but data says your biggest customer block is disappearing into another corridor.
Phase 2: Define Strategic Actions
Once you know the terrain, you pick your posture. And here’s where most organizations fail—they try to be in two quadrants at once. They “scale up” in one line while also “streamlining” another without clear separation of tactics. It’s messy, slow, and wastes resources.
Two postures deliver the quickest results:
- Scale Up and Seize Growth Opportunities: When costs and demand are both in your favor, you don’t tiptoe—you flood the zone. Expand Production, lock in suppliers, raise your profile in growing markets before rivals recover.
- Defend Margins and Expand Share: When demand is flat but you have a cost edge, you don’t chase volume—you make every unit count. Tighten cost discipline, poach customers from weaker rivals, deploy pricing where it hurts them most.
Anything else is just hoping the environment will magically reset.
Why this beats the usual “wait and see”
- You get a clear, evidence-based read on your competitive position.
- You lock into a posture fast, instead of dithering while opportunities expire.
- You avoid chasing markets that tariffs have already gutted.
- You create a repeatable process for the next trade shock.
Case Study
When tariffs hit components from its main supplier country, the instinct was to “wait out” the disruption. The framework forced a different look. The matrix placed them in “Restructure”—demand for their product was spiking in emerging markets, but costs were climbing. Instead of freezing, they renegotiated supplier contracts, shifted partial assembly to a lower-cost jurisdiction, and automated key steps. Within nine months, cost per unit fell enough to sustain margins while capturing the new demand wave.
FAQs
How do we know which quadrant we’re in if data is incomplete?
Use ranges and scenarios. You don’t need perfection—you need directional clarity.
Can we skip the matrix and jump to actions?
You can, but that’s gambling. You might get lucky, but you can’t build a strategy on luck.
What’s the fastest way to update our position?
Automate the cost and demand tracking for your core products so new data feeds straight into the matrix.
If we are in Streamline Focus, do we do nothing?
You do less—but with intent. Redirect resources to segments where conditions are better.
Closing Remarks
Most organizations treat tariffs like temporary headaches. That mindset is the real liability. The winners will be those that treat them as permanent variables—factored into every plan, every forecast, and every capital decision made.
The Tariffs and Global Trade framework doesn’t just help you survive these swings—it helps you weaponize them. The matrix tells you exactly where you stand. The phases tell you exactly what to do about it. And in a world where policy can flip faster than supply chains can react, having that clarity is the difference between leading the market and reading about it in someone else’s quarterly results.
Interested in learning more about the other phase of the framework? You can download an editable PowerPoint presentation on Tariffs and Global Trade: The Economic Impact on Business framework here on the Flevy documents marketplace.
Do You Find Value in This Framework?
You can download in-depth presentations on this and hundreds of similar business frameworks from the FlevyPro Library. FlevyPro is trusted and utilized by 1000s of management consultants and corporate executives.
For even more best practices available on Flevy, have a look at our top 100 lists:
Comments